Cook Out Milkshake Flavors: Complete List of 40+ Shakes
Dozens of flavors, real ice cream, and free flavor mixing. Below is a quick master list, flavors organized by category, a flavor finder, popular combinations, and honest notes on what’s confirmed versus compiled.
At a glance
- Cook Out’s official shake menu: “40+ Fresh Shakes”
- Flavor mixing: Widely known and commonly offered, though exact policy can vary by location
- Categories: Classic, candy, cheesecake, fruit, coffee, and seasonal
- Availability: Can vary by location and time of year
- Best way to confirm: Check your local Cook Out’s current menu board
Important: Cook Out uses “40+ Fresh Shakes” as its official branding, but doesn’t publish a text based master flavor list anywhere on its own website. The list below is compiled by cross referencing flavors that appear consistently across multiple independent Cook Out menu sources treat it as a practical reference, not a guaranteed official menu.
Here are the flavors that appear consistently across cross referenced Cook Out menu sources 33 in total, grouped loosely by type so it’s easier to scan:
Chocolate
Strawberry
Fresh Banana
Caramel
Pineapple
Peach
Fresh Watermelon
Cotton Candy
Walnut
Oreo
Oreo Mint
Orange Push Up
M&M
Reese’s Cup
Snickers
Butterfinger
Heath Toffee
Mint Chocolate Chip
Peanut Butter Fudge
Blueberry Cheesecake
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
Cherry Cheesecake
Cappuccino
Mocha
🍂 Caramel Apple
🍂 Pumpkin Pie
❄️ Fresh Eggnog
❄️ Peppermint Mocha
☀️ Key Lime Pie
Salted Caramel
That’s 33 individually named flavors we could cross reference and confirm across multiple sources see “Why doesn’t this add up to exactly 40+?” below for why that’s lower than Cook Out’s official headline number.
These categories are our own organization for readability Cook Out doesn’t publish official category names for its shakes.
Classic & Fruit Flavors
| Flavor | Notes |
|---|---|
| Vanilla | Common base for custom mixes |
| Chocolate | Standard year round flavor |
| Strawberry | Standard year round flavor |
| Fresh Banana | Standard year round flavor |
| Caramel | Standard year round flavor |
| Pineapple | Standard year round flavor |
| Peach | More commonly reported in warmer months |
Southern & Signature Flavors
| Flavor | Notes |
|---|---|
| Banana Pudding | Frequently mentioned as a signature flavor |
| Oreo | Frequently mentioned as a top pick |
| Oreo Mint | Mint + Oreo variant |
| Orange PushUp | Inspired by the classic frozen treat |
Candy & Chocolate Flavors
| Flavor | Notes |
|---|---|
| M&M | Candy pieces blended in |
| Reese’s Cup | Peanut butter + chocolate |
| Snickers | Caramel, chocolate, nuts |
| Butterfinger | Crunchy candy flavor |
| Heath Toffee | Nutty toffee |
| Mint Chocolate Chip | Mint + chocolate bits |
| Peanut Butter Fudge | One of the richer, more filling options |
Cheesecake Flavors
| Flavor | Notes |
|---|---|
| Strawberry Cheesecake | Frequently mentioned fan favorite |
| Blueberry Cheesecake | Fruit + cheesecake combo |
| Chocolate Chip Cheesecake | Cheesecake with chocolate chips |
| Cherry Cheesecake | Commonly reported as a spring offering |
Coffee Flavors
| Flavor | Notes |
|---|---|
| Cappuccino | Coffee forward flavor |
| Mocha | Coffee + chocolate |
Seasonal & Occasionally Reported Flavors
Seasonal availability can vary considerably by location and year. The season labels below are general guidance based on how sources describe them, not an official Cook Out seasonal calendar.
| Flavor | Commonly Reported Season |
|---|---|
| Apple Pie | Fall |
| Caramel Apple | Fall |
| Pumpkin Pie | Fall |
| Fresh Eggnog | Winter/holiday |
| Peppermint Mocha | Winter/holiday |
| Key Lime Pie | Spring/summer |
| Salted Caramel | Reported year round at some locations |
Some locations may also highlight a rotating spotlight flavor from time to time, though this varies by restaurant and isn’t something we can confirm as a fixed, chainwide program.
Cook Out officially describes its shake menu as “40+ Fresh Shakes,” but it doesn’t publish a searchable master text list anywhere on its own site. The names above are the flavors we were able to identify and cross reference across multiple independent Cook Out menu sources roughly 33 individually named flavors, which is lower than the official 40+ headline figure. Rather than pad the list with unverified names just to hit a round number, we’ve kept it to flavors we could reasonably confirm. If your local Cook Out has a flavor not listed here, that’s expected treat this page as a practical reference, not a claim to have found every single one.
Cook Out is widely known for letting customers combine flavors, commonly two at a time, and this is reported as available at no extra charge at many locations, though exact policy can vary by restaurant. This is a big part of why the shake menu feels much larger than “40+ flavors” on paper every pairing creates a new combination.
| Combination | Flavor Profile |
|---|---|
| Chocolate + Peanut Butter Fudge | Rich, nutty, Reese’s style |
| Strawberry + Fresh Banana | Fruity, creamy |
| Peanut Butter Fudge + Fresh Banana | Rich and filling |
| Peach + Cherry Cheesecake | Fruit forward, summery |
| Oreo + Mint Chocolate Chip | Double mint chocolate |
| Caramel + Vanilla | Simple, buttery classic |
If you imagine 40 flavors and allow any two different flavors to be paired, the number of unique two flavor combinations works out to 40 × 39 ÷ 2, or 780 possible pairings. That’s a useful way to understand why a “40+ flavor” menu can feel like it has far more options than the headline number suggests this is illustrative math based on the official flavor count, not a claim that Cook Out has verified or published this exact figure.
| If You Like… | Try These |
|---|---|
| Chocolate | Chocolate, Oreo, Reese’s Cup, Butterfinger, Heath Toffee, Peanut Butter Fudge, Mocha |
| Fruit | Strawberry, Fresh Banana, Peach, Pineapple, Fresh Watermelon, Cherry Cheesecake |
| Candy | M&M, Reese’s Cup, Snickers, Butterfinger, Heath Toffee |
| Cheesecake | Strawberry, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, or Cherry Cheesecake |
| Coffee | Cappuccino, Mocha |
How Much Is a Cook Out Milkshake?
Shake prices vary by flavor, size, and location, and can change over time, so we’re not going to state an exact figure here that could go stale. For current pricing, check your local restaurant’s menu board, or see our Complete Cook Out Menu & Prices guide for the most current reference we maintain.
Do Flavors Vary by Location?
Yes, in practice. While core flavors like Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Oreo, and Banana Pudding are consistently reported across locations, seasonal and specialty flavors can differ by restaurant and time of year. Don’t assume an online list, including this one, reflects exactly what’s on your local menu board today that board is always the most current source.
If you need to avoid gluten or have a gluten related allergy or sensitivity, don’t assume a Cook Out shake is safe without checking first. Shared equipment is commonly used to prepare different shake flavors and other menu items, which creates a cross contact risk. Ask your specific restaurant about ingredients and preparation practices before ordering if this matters for your health.
How many milkshake flavors does Cook Out have?
Cook Out officially markets its shake menu as “40+ Fresh Shakes.” We were able to cross reference and confirm roughly 33 individually named flavors across independent sources see “Why doesn’t this add up to exactly 40+?” above.
What is the most popular Cook Out milkshake flavor?
Oreo is one of the most frequently mentioned choices across sources, with Banana Pudding and Peanut Butter Fudge also commonly cited as fan favorites. This reflects how often these flavors come up in independent reporting, not an official Cook Out ranking.
Can you mix Cook Out milkshake flavors?
Yes. Cook Out is widely known for letting customers combine flavors, commonly two at a time, often at no extra charge though exact policy can vary by location.
Does Cook Out have seasonal milkshake flavors?
Yes. Flavors like Pumpkin Pie, Caramel Apple, and Fresh Eggnog are commonly reported in fall and winter, while Key Lime Pie and Fresh Watermelon show up more in spring and summer. Availability varies significantly by location and isn’t tied to a published official calendar.
Does Cook Out publish an official list of every milkshake flavor?
Not as a text list. Cook Out’s official website confirms “40+ Fresh Shakes” as branding, but its shakes page is a photo based menu board rather than a written flavor list.
Are Cook Out milkshakes gluten free?
Don’t assume so without checking. Shared equipment is commonly used across flavors and menu items, creating a cross contact risk ask your specific restaurant if this matters for your health.