Cook Out’s dessert menu is famous for one reason: the Fancy Milkshake. With over 40+ flavors that can be mixed and matched, the combinations are virtually endless. However, the menu also hides a few other gems like floats and cheesecake slices. From classic ice cream flavors to seasonal favorites, Cookout desserts are designed to be customizable, indulgent, and budget friendly. This guide covers milkshakes, floats, prices, calories, customization tips, popularity charts, and FAQs.
Cookout Milkshakes (Core Dessert)
Cookout milkshakes are the centerpiece of the dessert menu and are hand-spun, thick, and filling. With over 40 flavors, they are often ordered as a drink or upgraded tray side.
Milkshake Price & Size
| Item | Typical Price | Size |
| Regular Milkshake | $3.99–$4.49 | Large (approx. 16–20 oz) |
| Tray Upgrade Milkshake | +$1.00–$1.50 | Same size |
💡 Prices may vary slightly by location.
Most Popular Milkshake Flavors (2026)
These flavors dominate sales due to nostalgia, richness, and crowd appeal. They remain available year round unless marked seasonal.
| Flavor | Taste Profile |
| Oreo Mint | Cool, creamy, refreshing |
| Chocolate Chip Mint | Sweet with chocolate crunch |
| Reese’s Cup | Rich peanut butter & chocolate |
| Oreo | Thick, classic cookie flavor |
| Vanilla | Smooth and versatile |
Milkshake Flavor Popularity Chart
This chart reflects ordering trends across U.S. locations. Classic candy based shakes continue to outperform fruit options.
Oreo & Oreo Mint ██████████
Reese’s Cup ████████░░
Chocolate Chip Mint ███████░░░
Vanilla & Chocolate ██████░░░░
Fruit-Based Shakes █████░░░░░
Fruit & Lighter Milkshake Options
Fruit shakes offer a slightly lighter, fresher alternative to candy heavy desserts. They are popular during warmer months and pair well with grilled meals.
| Flavor | Notes |
| Strawberry | Sweet and classic |
| Banana | Creamy, smooth texture |
| Banana Pineapple | Tropical blend |
| Pineapple | Bright and tangy |
| Peach (Seasonal) | Sweet Southern favorite |
Specialty & Seasonal Desserts
Seasonal shakes create limited time demand and return yearly. These flavors often sell out faster during peak hours.
| Seasonal Item | Availability |
| Eggnog Shake | Winter |
| Pumpkin Pie Shake | Fall |
| Fresh Watermelon Shake | Summer |
| Peppermint Shake | Holiday season |
Calories & Nutrition Overview
Cookout desserts are intentionally indulgent, not low calorie treats. Portion size contributes heavily to calorie count.
| Dessert | Estimated Calories |
| Vanilla Milkshake | 550–600 |
| Oreo Milkshake | 700–750 |
| Reese’s Cup Shake | 750–800 |
| Chocolate Malt | 650–700 |
| Banana Shake | 600–650 |
Note: Values are estimates and vary by customization.
Floats & Simple Desserts
Floats provide a lighter dessert option with carbonation and ice cream. They are less filling but still satisfy a sweet craving.
| Item | Description | Calories |
| Coke Float | Cola + vanilla ice cream | ~350 |
| Cheerwine Float | Southern cherry soda float | ~360 |
Cookout Customization Guide
Cookout allows mix and match milkshake flavors at no extra cost. This feature is one of the brand’s biggest dessert advantages.
Popular combinations:
- Oreo + Peanut Butter
- Banana + Strawberry
- Chocolate + Reese’s
- Vanilla + Mint
💡 You can request extra thickness or lighter blending.
Best Desserts to Pair With Meals
Desserts at Cookout often serve as meal closers or tray upgrades. Balancing sweetness with savory items improves the overall experience.
| Meal Item | Best Dessert Pair |
| Burger & Fries | Oreo or Chocolate Shake |
| Hot Dogs | Vanilla or Banana Shake |
| Cajun Chicken | Mint or Strawberry Shake |
| BBQ Sandwich | Reese’s or Chocolate Malt |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
How many dessert options does Cookout have?
Cookout offers 40+ milkshake flavors plus floats and seasonal items.
Can I mix milkshake flavors?
Yes, most locations allow free flavor combinations.
Are desserts available late at night?
Yes, desserts are served during normal Cookout hours, often late-night.
Is a milkshake included in a tray?
Milkshakes are an optional paid upgrade from a regular drink.
Final Thoughts
Cookouts dessert menu is unmatched for variety, portion size, and value. Whether you want a classic shake or a creative mix, Cookout desserts deliver consistent satisfaction.
Pro tip: If visiting during peak hours, order desserts early to avoid seasonal sell outs.