The Cook Out Secret Menu isn’t an official printed list, but rather a collection of hacks and off menu combinations that loyal fans and employees have popularized. Because Cook Out’s kitchen is incredibly flexible with its ingredients (thanks to the milkshake station and tray system), you can customize almost anything. These items are often ordered by seasoned patrons and beloved for their bold flavors and creative twists.
What Is the Cookout Secret Menu?
The Secret Menu isn’t an official printed list, but rather a set of popular customer invented combos. Employees recognize many of these orders, and they can usually be made upon request. Most secret items are built from standard menu ingredients, just layered creatively.
How to Order Off the Secret Menu
Ordering from the Secret Menu is simple: just describe what you want at the counter. Use clear names like Animal Style Wrap or Grilled Cheese Box and they’ll help customize it.
TIP: Provide specifics on sauces, toppings, and order of assembly for best results.
Secret Entrees
These items modify the standard burgers and hot dogs using ingredients found elsewhere in the kitchen.
| Secret Item | Description | How to Order |
| The “Everything” Burger | A massive burger loaded with chili, slaw, onions, pickles, mustard, ketchup, mayo, lettuce, and tomato. | Ask for a Huge Burger, Cheddar Style and add Cook Out Style toppings to it. Basically, ask for every topping you have. |
| Peanut Butter Paradise | A burger topped with creamy peanut butter and bacon. The saltiness of the PB pairs perfectly with the char-grilled beef. | Order a Burger and ask to add Peanut Butter (from the shake station) and Bacon. |
| The Mexi-Dog | A spicy, southwest-style hot dog. | Order a Hot Dog with Chili, Cheddar Cheese, Texas Pete®, and Diced Onions. |
| Firecracker Hot Dog | For heat lovers. | Order a Hot Dog with Chili, Cheese, and ask for Cajun Seasoning on top. |
| Cheese Dog (No Meat) | A vegetarian-friendly “hot dog” that replaces the sausage with melted cheese. | Ask for a Cheese Dog, no hot dog. They will fill the bun with cheese, chili, and slaw. |
| Chicken Quesadilla “Texas Style” | A standard quesadilla upgraded with spicy sauce. | Order a Chicken Quesadilla and ask to add Texas Pete® and Extra Cheese. |
Note on the Peanut Butter & Pickle Sandwich: While not an official secret item, you can hack this viral snack by ordering a BLT (hold the bacon/lettuce/tomato) or a Grilled Cheese (hold the cheese) and asking for Peanut Butter and Pickles.
Secret Menu – Burgers & Sandwiches
These items take classic burgers and reimagine them with extra layering. They’re perfect if you want something indulgent and stacked.
| Secret Item | What It Is | Must-Ask For |
| Animal Style Burger | Burger with extra grilled onions & sauce | Add grilled onions + extra spread |
| Double Down Burger | Two patties with bacon & cheese | Ask for double patties + bacon |
| Bacon Ranch Club | Burger with ranch & extra bacon | Ranch drizzle + extra bacon |
| Big Cheesy Melt | Cheddar-style with cheese cups | Cheese cup inside burger |
Secret Wraps & Specialty Wraps
Wraps are portable, customizable, and hit the flavor sweet spot. Secret wraps usually include multiple proteins and bold sauces.
| Wrap Name | Core Ingredients | Notes |
| Animal Wrap | Burger + grilled onions + sauce | Same as Animal Style burger but wrapped |
| Grilled Cheese Wrap | American cheese + burger patty | Gooey melty goodness in a tortilla |
| Cajun Ranch Wrap | Cajun chicken + ranch | Spicy + cool contrast |
| Big Quesadilla Wrap | Chicken or beef + cheddar | Melty tex-mex vibe |
Legendary Hot Dog Spins
Hot dogs get elevated with toppings normally reserved for sauces and trays. These secret twists turn a simple hot dog into a loaded indulgence.
| Secret Dog | Toppings | How to Order |
| Bacon Bomb Dog | Bacon + cheese sauce | Ask for dog with bacon & cheese sauce |
| Chili Cheese Bacon Dog | Chili + cheese + bacon | All the toppings listed |
| Spicy Slaw Dog | Hot pepper slaw + mustard | Ask for slaw + hot peppers |
Secret Milkshakes
With 40+ flavors that can be mixed for free, the shake possibilities are endless. These are the community favorites.
| Secret Shake | Flavor Combo | How to Order |
| Banana Pudding “Bread” | Tastes exactly like freshly baked banana bread. | Order a Banana Pudding Shake and add Chocolate Chips and Walnuts. |
| The “Elvis” | A tribute to the King’s favorite sandwich. | Order a Peanut Butter Shake and add Fresh Banana. |
| Peach Cobbler | A fruity Southern classic with crunch. | Order a Peach Shake and add Nilla® Wafers. |
| Snickers® Cheesecake | Adds a tangy richness to the candy bar flavor. | Order a Snickers Shake and add a Cheesecake slice. |
| Chocolate Covered Strawberry | A romantic classic. | Order a Strawberry Shake and add Chocolate Chips (or Chocolate Syrup). |
| Orange Push-Up | Tastes like the classic orange cream popsicle. | Order an Orange Shake (or Vanilla with Orange syrup) and add Cheesecake. |
| Cappuccino Caramel | A frozen coffee delight. | Order a Cappuccino Shake and add Caramel. |
Pro Tip – The Mix In Rule: You can mix any flavors together. If you want a Watermelon Oreo Peanut Butter shake, they will make it. You can also ask for Extra Thick (less milk, more ice cream) or Thin (more milk) depending on your preference.
DIY Secret Menu Recipes
Here are step by step ways to order or make your own secret items at Cookout.
Animal Style Wrap
- Base: Large tortilla
- Add: Burger patty + grilled onions
- Top: Mustard + pickles + extra sauce
- Fold & serve
Note: This wrap mirrors the fan-favorite animal style with portability.
Big Cheesy Melt
- Order: Burger with two cheese cups
- Add: Extra cheese inside the buns
- Optional: Grilled mushrooms or onions
Note: Perfect for cheese lovers who want a gooey burger experience.
Spicy Slaw Dog
- Hot dog base
- Add: Spicy slaw + sport peppers
- Finish: Yellow mustard drizzle
Note: A spicy, tangy twist to the classic hot dog balanced with slaw.
Secret Menu Popularity Chart
This chart shows how often secret items are ordered relative to each other. Fan favorites rise to the top across Cookout locations.
Animal Style Burger ██████████
Bacon Ranch Club ████████░░
Cajun Ranch Wrap ███████░░░
Grilled Cheese Wrap ██████░░░░
Spicy Slaw Dog ██████░░░░
Mint Oreo Twist Shake █████░░░░░
Tips for Successful Secret Orders
👉 Be specific: Say exactly what toppings and sauces you want.
👉 Keep it simple: Too many add-ins can slow ordering.
👉 Remember costs: Secret items may cost extra for added ingredients.
Employees appreciate clarity the more precise your order, the better the result.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Is the Cookout Secret Menu official?
A: No it’s fan-driven but widely recognized by staff.
Q: Are secret items pricier?
A: Yes extra toppings and proteins usually cost a bit more.
Q: Can all locations make secret items?
A: Most can, but availability depends on local stock and staff familiarity.
Q: Do secret menu items come standard?
A: They require special instruction at ordering; they aren’t listed on boards.
Final Thoughts
Cookout’s secret menu lets you explore beyond the standard offerings with creativity and flavor. From stacked burgers to loaded dogs and dessert shakes, these custom orders are fan tested and party approved.
Note: Always check with your local Cookout to confirm ingredients and availability.